Discover Why Alkaline Ph Meals Is Suggested

An earlier version of this page was a list of food tips for travelling: whole grain pita instead of a sandwich, vegetables and lentils instead of ground meat, fruit cake instead of chocolate cake, water instead of fizzy drinks. It never explained why alkaline pH meals are suggested. This version does that, then runs those same travel swaps through the score that researchers use to rank foods as acid-forming or base-forming.
Where the suggestion comes from
A 2011 systematic review on dietary acid load and bone, by Fenton and colleagues (first author at the University of Calgary), opens with the idea in one line: “Modern diets have been suggested to increase systemic acid load and net acid excretion.” The next sentence says that, in response, alkaline diets and products “are marketed to avoid or counteract this acid” and to “help the body regulate its pH”.
The acid-load part can be measured. In 1995 Remer and Manz, at the Research Institute of Child Nutrition in Dortmund, calculated the potential renal acid load, or PRAL, of common foods. Their values ran from about 23.6 mEq per 100 g for certain hard cheeses, through 0 for fats and oils, down to roughly −3 for fruits, fruit juices and vegetables. They also found a correlation of r = .83 between net acid excretion and urine pH. So food does shift the acidity of urine, and the score predicts it.
What the same score does for bone is a different question. Fenton’s review screened 238 studies, of which 55 met its inclusion criteria, and concluded that “there is no evidence that an alkaline diet is protective of bone health.” The review’s stated objective was bone, so that conclusion covers bone only.
How the score is worked out
A 2013 review by Scialla and Anderson prints the PRAL formula next to food estimates adapted from Remer: PRAL = 0.49 × protein (g) + 0.037 × phosphorus (mg) − 0.021 × potassium (mg) − 0.026 × magnesium (mg) − 0.013 × calcium (mg). Protein and phosphorus push the number up. Potassium, magnesium and calcium pull it down. The figures below apply that formula to USDA FoodData Central records (SR Legacy, last updated April 2019), per 100 g.
The old travel swaps, scored
| Old tip | Swap out | PRAL | Swap in | PRAL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pita instead of a sandwich | White bread | +2.85 | Whole-wheat pita | +5.90 |
| Vegetables instead of ground meat | Ground beef, 85% lean, pan-browned | +12.90 | Boiled lentils | +2.15 |
| Raw spinach | −11.84 | |||
| Raw carrots | −5.71 | |||
| Raw courgette (zucchini) | −4.16 | |||
| Fruit cake instead of chocolate cake | Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting | −0.09 | Fruitcake | −0.71 |
| Water instead of fizzy drinks | Cola | +0.21 | Tap water | −0.07 |
| Herbal tea from home | Chamomile tea | −0.24 |
The bread swap goes the wrong way. Whole-wheat pita has 180 mg of phosphorus per 100 g against 98 mg in white bread, and only 15 mg of calcium against 144 mg, so its score comes out higher. That does not make white bread the better food. The formula has only five inputs, so fibre, for one, never enters it.
The meat swap is where the numbers move most in this set. Taking 85% lean beef as the ground meat, +12.90 drops to +2.15 with lentils, and spinach, carrots and courgette all score below zero. The cake and drink swaps barely move the score at all: under one point either way. The old page also paired olives with cheese. Ripe canned olives score −0.89. Taking feta as the cheese, it scores +11.22, close to the ground beef.
Where dates land on the same scale
The same formula puts Deglet Noor at −11.91 and Medjool at −13.67 per 100 g, near raw spinach. A 30 g portion comes to about −3.57 for Deglet Noor and −4.10 for Medjool. A search of FoodData Central’s SR Legacy, Foundation, Survey and Branded data finds one Mazafati record, a branded label entry that lists protein, potassium and calcium but not phosphorus or magnesium, so no PRAL can be worked out for Mazafati from it. Mazafati is also a very soft date that needs refrigeration, which is worth knowing before packing it for a long trip.
The NHS counts a 30 g portion of dried fruit, “such as currants, dates, sultanas and figs”, as 1 of your 5 A Day, and says it “should be eaten at mealtimes, not as a snack between meals, to reduce the impact on teeth”. On the road, that means dates with a meal stop rather than from the dashboard between stops.
What the score can and cannot tell you
PRAL tells you which way a food pushes urine acidity, and by roughly how much per 100 g. It cannot tell you a food is healthier overall, as the pita row shows, and the bone review above found no evidence that an alkaline diet protects bone. This page is general information, not medical advice.
Readers buying dates in bulk for a shop or an event can find the trade side in the site’s guide to dates wholesale for businesses and its notes on what shapes the price of wholesale dates.
More about this site is on the About Us page.